Does anyone have any experience comparing these two? I've been using the Marshall Powerbrake for 15 years. Never thought there would be a difference in these things.
I've read in this forum that some people think the Marshall Powerbrake sucks. Why? What about it makes it suck?
I understand that when you really turn down the volume on the Marshall, there is a tone difference, but I figure that's due largely to how your ears hear at different volumes and how the speakers sound at different volumes. I've seen reviews such as: "I'm 16 years old and been playing for 3 months, and when I played the Marshall Powerbrake, it sounded different, therefore it sucks!"
I"m looking for someone who can give me details. Why? Is the compression different? Of course I notice a compression/dynamic difference when really turning down the Marshall. I use the Marshall just like another review her in the forum: use as little attenuation as possible.
"Every note sounds like you're rattling a bunch of tin cans and old chicken bones around inside a plastic paint bucket."...Flealux ---------------- "Some bridges need burnin'"....Greg Koch
Post by billyguitar on Jan 15, 2006 12:43:34 GMT -7
The first attenuater I had was the Sholz. Next was the Marshall Power Brake. Next the Kendrick Air Brake. The last I bought was the THD. The Sholz definitely was the worst sounding. The Marshall a little better. The Kendrick better yet but awkward size. The best for me was the THD but I sent it back and had the attenuations clicks changed to 2 db each instead of 4 db. It is a very good sounding unit. As you said the whole key is to use as little attenuation as possible. I rarely used more than one or 2 clicks down. If I was playing blues or rock and had a non-master volume Z I would definitely have an attenuator. The Zs that have a master volume work so well that an attenuator wouldn't be an improvement. Tonewise the Marshall and the Sholz units really roll off the high end enough that you lose the sparkle. The newer/better designs retain more of the amp's natural sound. They really are a worthwhile expense, if you need to use one. I've never heard the Z atten. but I'm sure it's a good one.
77 guitars and 75 amps! "A noble spirit embiggens the smallest man." Jebediah Springfield www.luckysoandsos.com
Post by imyurhuckleberry on Jan 15, 2006 21:24:03 GMT -7
I just had someone ask me this not long ago, and I'll attach the answer I gave. I used a Marshall PB-100 for years, and just assumed it would be cool with my RxES, but it wasn't the case. It suffered tonally with the PB-100...as you know when you go through attenuation you can lose some sound characteristics that can only be achieved by playing at loud volumes. The Airbrake stays true to my tone as far as the actual sound that the amp produces, and from the minimum to maximum attenuation that the unit is designed for it does its job better than any other I have ever heard, and primarily because it does not rob the amp of its tone, the sound is the same just quieter. I found the Marshall PB-100 to be very much of a tone robber. But remember, that is with my RxES, the PB100 was fine with a JCM800. I'm not sure if it is the clean headroom that's affected by the PB100, or if the Z is just a better compliment. I will say the Airbrake sounds great through my Z, or my Marshall, and the PB100 only sounds good with a Marshall. Just my opinion though. Hope that helps.
Mazerati V2 Head
2x12 Z cab gold/blue
Maz 18 jr.
1969 Marshall Plexi Head
EVH III head
Friedman Dirty Shirley
GuitarZ: Best Pandemic Comment - Delivery guy shows up. As we're social distancing, I look at myself in brown loafers, black socks, gym shorts, t-shirt and say "I realize this is not my best look". His response "You can wear whatever you want to the apocalypse."
May 1, 2020 14:39:30 GMT -7
roscoenyc: read a newspaper.
May 19, 2020 17:20:32 GMT -7
roscoenyc: You know in school when they talked about "your permanent record"? Well, this is it! Learn to spell! Don't be stupid!
May 21, 2020 8:19:01 GMT -7
premiumplus (Dave): Due or do? Which or witch? Knob or nob? Their or there? Bass or base? Too much time on my hands...
May 24, 2020 6:31:30 GMT -7
roscoenyc: Ah, the incessant tire kickers. oh jeez.
May 25, 2020 6:57:46 GMT -7
GuitarZ: Needed some noise to fill a break in a tune I'm recording. It was too quiet. Just happened to have some High Quality Dr Z Ghia noise to fill the void. "Heal Your Sound with Dr Z! It's not just a guitar tone prescription!"
Jun 13, 2020 8:29:27 GMT -7
GuitarZ: Must be great to be a skunk. Eating bird food about 10' from our sun room. I'm clapping and yelling. At best, it might have given me one "yea what?" look while continuing to dine. At one point, there were two skunks and two racoons.
Jun 14, 2020 18:49:33 GMT -7
captainron (Ron): Hueter Toledo, just another business of today that doesn't care about tomorrow!
Jun 25, 2020 12:51:43 GMT -7
KeithA: Hueter Toledo....that business is gone to the dogs
Jun 26, 2020 8:22:26 GMT -7
easyed: Guitar Z, I encountered to ultimate garbage raiding combo once. We'd been having problems with the garbage cans being raided by raccoons for weeks. Late in the evening I heard rattling at the cans. I went out and found that he'd allied with a skunk. "OK"
Jun 30, 2020 11:40:27 GMT -7
GuitarZ: EasyEd - Someone at work topped us both. The inside of their car had been somewhat ransacked. They were blaming their son. They checked the video. It was a Bear! I'll stick with the racoons, skunks, foxes, and squirrels.
Jul 1, 2020 16:47:50 GMT -7
bigboki: In this age and time when everybody are struggling and especially S&Ms I am amazed to see that kind of ignorance. I am really sorry for your experience dear Dr Z but it is for the better. You don't want to do business with those kind of people anyway.
Jul 4, 2020 8:17:40 GMT -7
GuitarZ: Didn't want to restart the plumbing thread, so I figured I'd ShoutBox this. How the heck does cleaning the aerator on a faucet cause a leak to start under the faucet? Huh? Arggggh!!!!
Jul 10, 2020 7:40:17 GMT -7
The Bad Poodle Experience: well, Mike, it shouldn't have been the cause of a leak. double-check your work.
Jul 10, 2020 12:56:49 GMT -7
GuitarZ: I updated in the Plumbing thread that the Moen website says that a faulty aerator can cause a handle/base leak. Eiyy! I really don't understand how plumbing works. I was ready to double check all connections. But, the leaking stopped with cleaned Aerator.
Jul 11, 2020 18:13:56 GMT -7